In a nutshell the GAD approach was a better approach to the WID; therefore the gad approach liberates, empowers and promotes partnership and equitable distribution of resources and benefits.
Let us consider two that are among the most closely related: Rather than sustain an artificial division between comparative politics and international relations, in this book we explicitly take account of the global context in which the politics of a country takes shape.
The framework helps to inspire action plans that help address the problems with the labor pool. When investment is made in the education of girls, the return lasts for generations.
It was often claimed that a failure to fully integrate women Wid and gad development efforts would be a waste of human resources. However some have criticized this approach as being very western.
It should also be noted that the biggest contribution of GAD is the inclusion of men into the approach. Equally, although we understand that theorizing about such large questions as why countries have the political orders they do is asking a great deal, comparative politics has never shied away from asking big questions about the origins of regime types and their impact on world history.
It served as a comprehensive overview of the social, economic and political realities of development. It considers the modern day women who are involved in activities at workplaces and at home in trying to improve the society.
GAD concentrate more on the idea that women must be lifted from poverty and contribute more to the developments efforts. Gender is not determined biologically, as a result of sexual characteristics of either women or men, but is constructed socially. Because of the vast generalizations given, there are only stereotypes on which to go on for the examination using this concept.
A first group of comparativists maintain that what matters most is material interests. GAD Non-Applicable in the global north: Yet, within our world of states, no two are ruled in exactly the same way. At that time, Americans suddenly found themselves in a position of leadership, with a need for deep knowledge about a huge number of countries.
Strategic interests are long-term, related to improving women's position. The Effectiveness Approach EA originated in the s. Men expect women to be able to stretch the household's income to cover all necessities and leave some over for entertainment.
First, it universalized the particular experience of the West into a model that all countries, independent of time or place, would also follow. This also includes the disproportionate ratio of women to men in the job market and at leadership position, low level of education among women, and low socio-economic status among women.
With the rise and popularity of the term gender, came with its misusage of its actual meaning. Most international development agencies applied a very western approach towards helping these nations develop. Women need to be recognized in the south as being important components, because without that recognition, these nations will continue to suffer.COMPARE AND CONTRAST THE WOMEN IN DEVELOPMENT (WID) APPROACH AND THE GENDER AND DEVELOPMENT (GAD) Gender by definition refers to the characteristics, trades, attributes or even roles that are expected for males and females by a given culture or society.
Wid Wad and Gad Essay. Cambridge University Press – Comparative Politics: Interests, Identities, and Institutions in a Changing Global Order – Second Edition Edited by Jeffrey Kopstein and Mark Lichbach Excerpt More information CHAPTER ONE What Is Comparative Politics?Wid Wad and Gad.
Question: Briefly discuss the following theories and show the strengths and weaknesses of each approach to Gender Development; WID, WAD and GAD. Gender relates to the social constructions and relations between men and women and it does not simply look at maleness or femaleness.
From WID to GAD: Conceptual Shifts in the Women and Development Discourse Shahrashoub Razavi Carol Miller Occasional Paper 1, February United Nations Research Institute for Social Development. The GAD approach, which was developed in the s, stepped away from both WID and WAD and was founded in socialist-feminist ideology (Rathgeber,p).
WID, GAD, and PACA Six session plans provide basic knowledge about Women in Development (WID), Gender and Development (GAD), and Participatory Analysis for Community Action (PACA).
In addition to an overview session, there is an introductory session on .Download